Friday, March 11, 2011

Humanitarian and Human Rights Sites to Watch

ICRC (International Committee of the Red Cross/Red Crescent) here

Free Aafia dot org (Family Site) here

Marjorie Cohn (President of the National Lawyers Guild) Author of recent thorough book on US and Torture here

The author of the Guantanamo Files and MUCH more on Gitmo/related here

No More Gitmos here

World Can't Wait here

Also check out Talking Points Memo -- especially Ondelette,
Readers Supported Media; David Swanson's War is a Crime; Common Dreams, Counter Currents, Stephen Lendman and Stephen Soldz' Psychoanalysts Against the War

Wednesday, March 9, 2011

Habeas Corpus/McKeon Bill Would Exclude Holder From Detainee Decisions


find this article at Talking Points Memo here

Sens. John McCain (R-AZ) and Lindsey Graham (R-SC) are teaming up with Republicans on the House Armed Services Committee to write legislation that would take decisions about trying detainees out of the attorney general's hands and hand that power to the secretary of defense.

In the wake of the White House's new executive order allowing Guantanamo detainees to be held indefinitely, House Armed Services Committee Chairman Buck McKeon (R-CA) unveiled legislation that would, among other things, affirm the military's right to detain, hold and interrogate detainees at its discretion without Department of Justice or Attorney General Eric Holder involvement.

McKeon said he was working with McCain and Graham to craft a bill that would try to gain traction in both chambers.

Such legislation could attract significant Democratic support, considering Democrats' willingness to buck Obama's attempts to shutter Guantanamo Bay and Holder's decision to try Khalid Sheik Mohammed in civilian court in New York City, a decision that was later reversed after prominent Democrats, including Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) vigorously opposed the move.

In a striking move late last year when Democrats still controlled the House majority, they attached a provision to a $1.1 trillion resolution to keep the government funded next year that would prevent Obama from spending any funds to try terrorism suspects in civilian court instead of military commissions.

"Our military, not the Department of Justice, should be leading on law of war issues," Rep. Tom Rooney (R-FL), a reservist in the Army's Judge Advocate General program who serves on the Armed Services panel, told reporters Tuesday afternoon.

The bill also would formally authorize use of military force against al-Qaeda, the Taliban and affiliated terrorist networks; create certain restrictions which would make it tougher for detainees to return to the battlefield or share information with other terrorists or malign actors; and would permanently block funding for the creation or renovation of any facility in the continental United States to house detainees currently held at Guantanamo.

The House GOP move comes just as the Obama administration is preparing to open military-commission proceedings at Guantanamo Bay against Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, the accused mastermind of the USS Cole bombing in 2000. Al-Nashiri's trial would be the first new military trial of a suspected terrorist in more than two years, National Journal reports.

Although McKeon said he was working on the bill with the Armed Services Committee's ranking member, Adam Smith (D-WA), and had talked to him about it, one Democratic aide said the minority was not consulted about the bill's unveiling and was surprised by the one-sided approach.

McKeon said he expected broad Democratic support for the legislation.

"We think there will be a huge number of Democrats supporting the bill," he told reporters.

The proposal faces higher hurdles in the Senate but could attract some Democratic support there.

===========

Related Items:

Obama Approves Life Imprisonment Without Trial for Gitmo Prisoners here

Clive Stafford Smith on Prisoners Legal Limbo GO to Cage Prisoners dot com or CLICK here

Notice this one is from Fox News...so you know how to handle - still important occasionally to see what is over the air for such a great percentage of our US public. Obama's Gitmo Bay Course Reversal here

Find the following at No More Gitmos: News Digest for March 9, 2011 here
03/09 / Editorial / Washington Post / Mr. Obama's Gitmo order is a half step in the right direction

03/09 / Editorial / New York Times / The Prison That Won’t Go Away

03/09 / Richard A. Serrano and David G. Savage / Los Angeles Times / Cole bombing suspect to face military tribunal at Guantanamo

03/09 / Adam Serwer / Washington Post / Conservatives claiming "vindication" for Bush on Gitmo are wrong

03/09 / KHTS News (California) / McKeon And Arms Committee Announces New Legislation Aimed At Guantanamo

03/09 / Dennis Wagner / The Arizona Republic / Phoenix lawyer aids Gitmo suspect - for free. Attorney: 'We cannot lose our moral anchors'

03/09 / Dal LaMagna / Huffington Post / Thank You Republicans For Guantanamo

03/09 / Editorial / Los Angeles Times / Mired in Guantanamo

03/08 / Mara Liasson / NPR / Obama's Order Ends Difficult Chapter On Guantanamo

03/08 / Editorial / Wall Street Journal / Obama Ratifies Bush. The Administration embraces military tribunals at Gitmo.

03/08 / Associated Press / Republicans push for tougher Guantánamo limits

03/08 / Daphne Eviatar / Huffington Post / New Obama Admin Procedures Import Troubling Aspects of Afghanistan Detention Review to Gitmo

03/08 / Laura E. Lee / Southern Maryland Online / Guantanamo Military Tribunals Differ from U.S. Trials

03/08 / Jeffrey Kaye / Firedoglake / Isolation: “The Ideal Way Of ‘Breaking Down’ A Prisoner”

03/08 / Glenn Greenwald / Salon / Obama's new executive order on Guantanamo

These and other items at No Gitmos dot org here

Monday, March 7, 2011

Raymond Davis and Dr. Aafia Siddiqui: How America keeps messing up ties with Pakistan

Logo from the blogsite: About Aafia

The relationship of the US to Pakistan is - perhaps - the most obvious case today of trouble brewing to the point of no return among those with whom Americans interact daily. There are many reasons and many cases which have fueled this situation over many decades of course. Yet in the five or so years I've watched Pakistan and America interact, I've never seen things more volatile.

Somehow last year's fiasco with the Dr. Aafia Siddiqui case set the stage for the Raymond Davis incident to fuel rage to the point of nearly endless damage. Perhaps these fires could be paralleled to the burning of oil in a gigantic oil spill out of control. In both cases there have been a multitude of smaller incidents which the most aware could have seen as predictive of what would come. Yet, finally there are crucial incidents which explode into major trouble and those affected only ask weakly, 'How on earth could this have happened'? Here is my attempt to answer this question.

When Dr. Aafia Siddiqui was tried in a lower Manhattan courthouse (New York, New York) a year ago last January, I was there for the entire trial. I had already followed Aafia's case intently for years - along with many other US and international journalists.

I saw the handwriting on the wall - as did many other writers usually under the radar - that there were a number of cover-ups. This was obvious in the misleading and scarcity of commentary and reporting from the mainstream US media as well as from military/government spokespersons which were dogmatic or deliberately misleading concerning Aafia's guilt. Disguising or blacking-out what really happened was also obvious because there were "facts" given which in time had to be corrected often by "facts" diametrically opposite to the ones given earlier.

One common pattern in US media was to use headings labeling Aafia an "al Qaeda mom" and hinting that her Neuroscience degree was somehow related to bioweaponry. She'd never been charged a member of al Qaeda. Her degree was related to cognition - especially pertaining to how children learn and had nothing to do with chemistry. Misleading journalism and reporting was true of both Pakistan and the US - yet I'm here addressing problems mostly in US procedures and handling of such sensitive cases. Both the Davis and the Siddiqui case go well beyond the usual such rights questions in impacting US and Pakistani ties.

Unfortunately, even some of the human rights groups withdrew from the layers and complications in the Aafia Siddiqui case which may have involved some aspects of torturing in order to get information and contacts from Aafia. As often happens, if there's any indication that there's a murky link, there's a major pull-out of skittish rights groups. Yet, as at least one key article indicated, the victim became the criminal. Now most readers who are reading this know the pattern: this is how all too many perpetuators of abuse cover-up for their own crimes.

Dr. Aafia's trial was full of unseemly and unconstitutional license in and right outside the courthouse. For beginnings: the trial took place too close to the scene of the 911 tragedy, the comments of the judge were highly condescending to Dr. Aafia and he incessantly underlined to the jury what they were NOT to allow to influence them. Like Aafia said in court, it was as if Judge Berman held up a large warning sign which yelled, "Don't Go Here", while thereby bringing plenty of attention to certain very sketchy made-up theories unfit for the trial and unrelated to the charge.

All these strange actions continued to fan the flames of the fear-mongering done daily in the New York media, in the barring from Pakistan journalists from the early part of the trial, in requiring strict body searching and identification (which had to be written down without the court saying where such ID info would be sent) -especially for any who looked Muslim or foreign - before allowing entry to the courtroom. These procedures were followed all day long even if the person already searched and identified remained on the same floor of the courtroom between breaks.

The reporting from the New York Times (who's reporter was absolutely clueless as to the issues involved.) was among the most problematic.

One Pakistani "drop-in official" added his own misleading insinuations and flamed even more fear - of this tiny, fragile, abused 90 pound woman - in his whispered rumors in and out of the courtroom - before the trial had even concluded.

Other influential attenders, reporters and participants in the courtroom - given commands from 'higher up' were complicit in ignoring one of the major premise of democratic rule of law - ie - that the defendent is to be considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

So although the actual cases of Dr. Aafia and so-named "Raymond Davis" were entirely different, the parallel cases do strike similar chords. They illustrate why other nations see the US operating today in this so-called "war on terror" as people who continually say "do as I say, not as I do". How can any respect across nations come from this?

A bully nation is getting by with blatant abuse of Dr. Aafia - including her indictment by a swayed jury where there were no finger marks on the weapon, where no one was hurt by the accused -let alone murdered. Aafia's now imprisoned in an institution famous for the abuse of women. She's in for a ludicrous number of years well beyond an average lifetime (just in case, of course, she should outlive her captors by a longshot) so that the secrets of the US would die with her. She's refused return to her nation, her children, her sister and mother - even in exchange for "Raymond Davis".

To add injury to insult, her own blood brother, who lives and practices medicine in Texas, the same state as the institution where Aafia is incarcerated - not allowed even a short visit. (With no explanation given - and even while his application has passed all criteria for such a visit.) What kind of world-aware citizen would fail to recognize that such treatment could lead to anything but rage? How can American officials keep speaking out of both sides of the ugly american mouth without fallout? Fortunately, there's an peace action scheduled in front of Carswell on April.

Many Pakistani leaders and scholars remember for years the harmony begun when Pakistan became a democracy. The US was the only foreign country whose representative attended the birth of Pakistan on August 15, 1947 ** What has happened since then? Pakistan and America might have continued to be twin havens among the world's enemies a united demonstration of the value of democracy and goodwill between nations. Of course the problems since 1947 are multi-tiered and the responsibilities for difficulties lie somewhat buried underneath the rubble of history in both countries. Yet, here my purpose is to address mostly the mote in the eye of the "official" American.

Since so many others are writing about the "Raymond Davis" incident,I don't need to demonstrate further how his name and Aafia's are often in the same commentary. See "Raymond Davis and Norms of Justice" in this morning's Pakistan Tribune
by Amjad Malik Sahib provides some clear answers - should any Americans still ask the question: Why is Pakistan and Pakistani's justice system so stubbornly refusing to return Davis immediately into the hands of the US?

What about the kind of US "officials", diplomats, contractors and those they hire to go abroad? What about a few independently operating US cowboys with rather magical-thinking schemes of being one man empire savers such as Duane Clarridge (who wants to compete with both the CIA and keep Rush Limbaugh and Fox news and even The Washington Post supplied with half-truths?)

All the above American "outlaws" in the world at large keep predictably destroying the nation's once amiable reputation in the world. What could be less harmful to any well-meaning intentions for mutual security and reduction of terror than the way "the ugly American" keeps behaving toward other peoples as if they could do anything they please and make it "right" or legal AFTER each misled action?

That the murder by drones ceased for a short reprieve when "Raymond Davis" shot two Pakistanis was worthy of asking why. Yet once again, the drones drone on at the loss of many lives (even discussed in this morning's BBC news) and leading not only to wrecked lives on every hand yet continuing to be a strong recruiting tool for the many youngsters who watch such harm to their area and families.

That the US military would continue to drop their heartless video-controlled weaponry from the sky after a short reprieve - unabated - and at great ongoing risk to civilians in both Afghanistand an Pakistan shows an arrogance and disregard so outragish it smacks of laughable strategy naivete - were the results not so hellish.

Then, as mentioned here, add the poorly-informed if not downright injust and manipulated actions of US representatives in the cases of Dr. Aafia Siddiqui and "Raymond Davis".

How did America come to assume that this occupation of other nations (usually without the clear approval of the people themselves on both sides of the world) for alleged benevolent reasons (when most know it's for oil, location and other resources) could continue indefinitely without great outcries from many corners?

By what standard have the US representatives abroad and certain patronized officials in Pakistan come to assume they could act on their own and without the clear approval of the people at large? (Either Pakistan or the US?) Seldom any longer can "aid" money, weaponry, former western influence or any other assumed "entitlement" justify such denial, pressure and bullying. Nor will any media which continues to allow the government to stifle their written integrity - with pleas, perks, demands or even threats - survive for long as journalism.

No more can officials anywhere mutually cover-up for one another without some group of "the people" somewhere finding out key pieces of the truth. No more is it possible for any nation to hide behind such self-justifications as might, intelligence, wealth or "entitlement".

No country, no official in our times is likely to survive for long (especially among among the scholars of rights) by expecting or demanding differential or exeptional treatment. Or if perchance there would continue to be such occasions - upon discovering such expectation without justification - the fury of the people affected will come back to haunt the peoples of such a nation which keeps producing and sending out such poorly-groomed representatives.

By Connie L. Nash

===================
here
"Raymond Davis"

photo framed
by Anwaar Hussain -
the author of the
first OpEd on the Davis
case originally entitled
* "Everybody Loves Raymond"

** See early archives on the Aafia Siddiqui case in the blog "About Aafia" from an award-winning biographer of the life and thought of Allama Iqbal - beloved poet, philosopher and visionary the world over and the major spiritual guide for the founding of Pakistan. Note the striking stated theme of this blogsite: "US was the only foreign country whose representative attended the birth of Pakistan on August 15, 1947. The Case of Dr. Aafia Siddiqui appears as an epitome of entangled issues which seem to threaten this proverbial alliance, and hence also prospects of peace in the region. This is about saving a bridge." GO here and the official family site on Dr. Aafia Siddiqui here

See recent releases at The International Justice Network here

Plz go to the post below for another recent OpEd and references

Raymond Davis and Norms of Justice

Monday March 07, 2011 (15:28 PST)
Pakistan Tribune
paktribune.com

Columnist, Amjad Malik, is a life member of Supreme Court Bar Association and & a Solicitor-Advocate of the Supreme Court - UK

Legal circles have noted with great anguish and expressed its concerns on the extra judicial killing of at least three Pakistani citizens by a foreigner Raymond Davis and his colleagues at Lahore(Pakistan) on Thursday 27 Jan 2011. Public has condemned in the strongest words the free movement of diplomatic staff without protocol and prior permission bringing public safety and state security to a questionable risk quite contrary to the spirit of Vienna Convention and Counsellor relations 1961 and 1963.

Lawyers have sought Justice in the killings of 3 Pakistani citizens at Lahore involving USA mission staff demanding the Chief Justice of Pakistan and the Govt of Pakistan to ensure justice which is seen to be done to avoid miscarriage of justice, and inequality. This is the biggest test of the current civil administration since its election on February 2008, as if they are a little negligent, it will pave way for public outcry akin to Tunisia which have the potential to smite all who stand in between justice, fair play, equality and the free motion of the law of the land. All those involved in such crimes must be brought to books in accordance with the law of the land if they are not registered diplomats as required by the law. Any back dating will have a disastrous effects on the state relations and public confidence on Govt dealings with USA and will attract a backlash due to foreign interference in Pakistan.

It reminds us that no leniency was shown in the case of Dr Afia Siddiqui and law of the land prevailed in USA so must be the case in this murder probe and stern action must be ensued against perpetrators to avoid public outrage due to prevailing hatred present in the society due to ongoing war on terror. Critics observe that criminals must be treated as criminals not as ‘Pakistani’ criminals and or ‘USA’ criminals and same treatment must be bestowed what would have been meted out to any Pakistani citizen if involved in similar charges in USA. Only justice may provide temporary relief in this tragic episode. We observe that Vienna convention gives immunity to only listed top level diplomats and all at sundry at embassy is not automatically exempt or immune from criminal prosecution.

It is also noteworthy that Western laws are very clear in this regard as we saw in January 2011,that an Indian diplomat Anil Verma left UK due to fear of prosecution when his wife complained of a domestic violence and a debate ensued in UK inviting the Govt to probe the matter despite diplomatic immunity. On 20 October 2010 a Saudi prince Saud Abdulaziz bin Nasser al Saud has been jailed for life for murdering his servant Bandar Abdulaziz, 32, who was found beaten and strangled on 15 February 2010 at a hotel in central London. The prince was convicted and sentenced on the murder charge of his servant despite claiming immunity. Case of Georgian diplomat convicted in high speed crash killing a teen age U.S girl in 1997 and Libyan embassy debacle where constable Yvonne Fletcher was shot dead in 1984 which resulted in 15 years diplomatic relation between UK and Libya are examples which guide us to adopt the way of sanity than unrest, bloodshed.

Raymond’s case cannot go to ICJ until Pakistan agrees, local courts are to rule on this case if he is not a diplomat like Dr Afia Siddiqui’s case which never went to ICJ despite clear conflicts. The proposed appplication of a citizen of USA should be detested as submiting to the jurisdiction of that court will negate Pakistan’s right to try any criminal in their court.Compare it with Dr afia Siddiqui, if it proves that she was kidnapped, can Pakistani court take cognisance and recover her, even then ICJ will have to be invoked for which consent of both countries will be required.Any aggrived in Lahore killing may also invoke ICJ for relief in the matter of the alleged killing, conspiracy and compenation with the consent of contarcting states”.The ICJ is the principal judicial organ of the UN. It has a dual role, to settle in accordance with international law the legal disputes submitted to it by “states,” and to give advisory opinions on legal questions referred to it “duly authorised international organs and agencies.”

The court is competent to entertain a dispute “only” if the states concerned have accepted its jurisdiction in one of three ways that are specified in the ICJ’s jurisdiction provisions. These need not be mentioned here in detail as they are not applicable in this case for reasons mentioned further. However, in brief, the competency of the court is activated in disputes between states where certain arbitration provisions between state agreements specifically refer disputed matters to the ICJ when states are embroiled in a dispute. In doubtful matters the court will decide for itself whether it has jurisdiction to hear and decide on the dispute. This is the pertinent issue in this case. The ICJ’s role is to decide in accordance with international law disputes of a legal nature that are submitted to it by states.

Therefore, only States may be parties to cases before the ICJ, this is in accordance with its role as stipulated in the opening paragraph of Article 1 of the UN Charter. It is conceivable that such proceedings could be between a state on one hand and an international organisation, a collectivity or an individual on the other. Within their respective field of jurisdiction, institutions such as the Court of Justice of the European Communities or the Eurpoean Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg would be entitled to hear disputes as mentioned above. This is not the cas, however, with the ICJ, to which no case cann be submitted unless both applicant and respondent are States.

Despite various proposals and even the existence of a treaty providing for the possibility of proceedings before the court between an internatiional agency and a state, neither the UN nor any of its specialised agencies can be a party in contentious proceedings before the ICJ. As for private interests, these can only form the subject of proceedings in the ICJ if a state, relying on international law, takes up the case of one of its nationals and invokes against another state the wrongs which its national claims to have suffered at the latters hands, the dispute thus becoming one between states. Like any other court, the ICJ can only operate within the constitutional limits that have been laid down for it. The registry receives written or oral applications from private persons daily. However, heart-rending, however well-founded such applications may be, the ICJ is unable to entertain them and a standard reply is always sent; “UnderArticle 34 of the Statute only States may be parties in cases before the court.”

Therefore issues of jurisdiction, exhaustion of appeal rights in the local jurisdiction, or merits of the case need not be further dwelled upon as any case brought by US involves allegedly Pakistani state and they may not be brought to the jurisdiction of the ICJ’sremit without consent of those parties. I strongly oppose to submit to the juridiction of ICJ and diasgree any officials attending that court hearing and all parties must respect and submit to the jurisdiction of Pakistani Superior Courts and if any dispute other options of prisoners exchnage, pardon and sharia compliance are available as a means to remove the deadock, if any. If submitted against the public opinion to ICJ now then the judgemnet will have to be accepted by both parties and Pakistani courts will never be able to try any foregner in their jurisdiction as despite willingness visiting states will protect their citizens whether accused or otherwise and will take the matter to ICJ for protection, delay and recovery of their citizens and compensation will be left as an only option with regret and repentance which will be a dangerous trend for a newly born free and independent judiciary of Pakistan.

In this context murder whether intentional or unintentional is a serious crime against state and unless proper probe is conducted & completed and a judicial process takes place, the arrested US diplomat must not be allowed to leave the jurisdiction without judicial oversight as no one is above the law as per the Constitution of Pakistan 1973. It will be a survival test of the govt of Pakistan in the light of Dr Afia Siddiqui’s arrest, detention, trial, conviction and sentence post severe protest of Pakistani public and still United States law of the land prevailed and so must be the case in respect of the law of Pakistan. Having said that parity must be maintained ensuring Raymond Davis and his colleagues a counsellor access forthwith, and a fair trial, with access to their lawyer of choice with interpreter, food and medical aid. There are solutions emanating from conviction of Raymond whether he admits it, or State prosecution proves it beyond a reasonable doubt. Without conviction all solution promotes anarchy, dissatisfaction and .....?

amjadlaw@aol.com

---------
� Copyright 2003-2004 PakTribune
Site powered and maintained by RMDG.org And PakCyber.Com

See also the Newsweek - Pakistan version of an earlier blogpost here

See a helpful list of references here updated for March 5, 2011

Son of Dr. Aafia in 2008 What sort of legacy is the US leaving to the children of Pakistan let alone America?

Saturday, March 5, 2011

Xe and the Raymond Davis Case


NOTES:

"Raymond Davis" shot dead two Pakistanis in a highly controversial case -

Called by US officials a "diplomat", Davis' legal clearance to travel in Pakistan
was only attempted AFTER the crime.

Authorities have found evidence he's likely to have been working for Xe or Blackwater
(among other possible connections) -

Many Pakistanis have reason to believe that Davis has been involved in highly dangerous and sensitive operations not cleared by the appropriate Pakistan officials nor agreed to by the Pakistani people they represent. As far as complicity by the US public at large, there is almost no awareness by anyone I speak with about the Raymond Davis case. Like many other events and people who represent Americans, the knowledge of such is more and more lacking in transparency and being effectively kept out of congress and media by a numbed out nation.

The actions in response to this incident - on the part of Americans has been the demand to remove Davis from Pakistan immediately. With talk out of both sides of the mouth, US officials have exchanged so-called facts for other so-called facts - none of which have been weighed and found accurate by any standard except the officials which want Davis "out of there" and in a hurry. In the meantime, Davis apparently shows no humility nor respect toward Pakistani cultures, rules or religion - yet continues to demand exceptional treatment from Pakistani authorities as if he's the "big man on the block" even after he's the perpetrator of these recent problems abroad. The OpEd above and the one below highlight and underline a number of the reasons such acts of disregard and self-serving patronizing can no longer be dismissed nor occur in a vacuum.

Among the singular points which strike me as keen recent examples of these warnings:

Upon what basis would the Pakistani people and the officials who've been elected to represent them trust such pressures? What about the international conventions agreed to by the two nations? What about clear rule of law? And how could the people of Pakistan be expected they trust a US system - which has so unreasonably locked up Aafia ("the Daughter of the Nation") be trusted to be equitably just in the "Davis" case?

Also see Source Watch for Xe here

and Xe references at Wikipedia here

END NOTES by Connie L. Nash
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Friday, March 4, 2011

Duane Clarridge: Pakistan/Afghanistan/US Relations


New York Times Photo


Those interested in longrange diplomacy,
peace-making and justice --

might want to ask urgently:

Why is the former CIA superviser who lied
about the Iran-Contra affair and who carries
(or has carried) a taser gun, Duane Clarridge,
involved at all in Afghanistan/Pakistani/US interactions?

Here are a few background items for starters:

Duane Clarridge Defends the Empire here

Paul Hosefros/THE NEW YORK TIMES January 23, 2011
After a lengthy CIA career in which he co-founded the Counterterrorism Center, Duane Clarridge was pushed out in the wake of his indictment in 1991 on charges of lying to Congress. Now 78, Clarridge runs a donor-financed spy network that mixes foreign intelligence with his schemes for undermining the Karzai government.

By Mark Mazzetti

THE NEW YORK TIMES

WASHINGTON — Duane Clarridge parted company with the CIA more than two decades ago, but from poolside at his home near San Diego, he still runs a network of spies.

Over the past two years, he has fielded operatives in the mountains of Pakistan and the deserts of Afghanistan. Since the U.S. military cut off his funding in May, he has relied on private donors to pay his agents to keep gathering information on Taliban leaders and the secrets of Kabul’s ruling class.

Hatching schemes that are something of a cross between a Graham Greene novel and Mad Magazine’s “Spy vs. Spy,” Clarridge has sought to discredit Ahmed Wali Karzai, the Kandahar power broker who has long been on the CIA payroll, and planned to set spies on his half brother, President Hamid Karzai, in hopes of trying to prove — perhaps with beard clippings — Clarridge’s suspicions that the Afghan president was a heroin addict, associates say.

His dispatches — an amalgam of fact, rumor, analysis and uncorroborated reports — have been sent to military officials who, until last spring at least, found some credible enough to be used in planning strikes against militants in Afghanistan. They are also fed to conservative commentators, including Oliver North, a compatriot from the Iran-Contra scandal and now a Fox News analyst, and Brad Thor, an author of thrillers and a frequent guest of Fox’s Glenn Beck.

It shows how the outsourcing of military and intelligence operations has spawned legally murky clandestine efforts that can be at cross-purposes with America’s foreign policy goals. Despite Clarridge’s keen interest in undermining Afghanistan’s ruling family, President Barack Obama’s administration appears resigned to working with Hamid Karzai and his half brother, who is widely suspected of having ties to drug traffickers.

The Pentagon official who arranged a contract for Clarridge in 2009 is under investigation over allegations of violating Defense Department rules in awarding that contract. Because of the continuing inquiry, most of the dozen current and former government officials, private contractors and associates of Clarridge’s who were interviewed for this article would speak only on the condition of anonymity.

Clarridge, 78, declined to be interviewed but issued a statement saying that his operation, called the Eclipse Group, “may possibly be an effective model for the future, providing information to officers and officials of the United States government who have the sole responsibility of acting on it or not.”

From CIA chief to free agent

Clarridge joined the CIA during its freewheeling early years. He eventually became head of the spy agency’s Latin America division in 1981 and helped found the CIA’s Counterterrorism Center five years later. He was indicted in 1991 on charges of lying to Congress in the Iran-Contra scandal but was later pardoned by President George H.W. Bush.

Now, more than two decades after Clarridge was forced to resign from the intelligence agency after the Iran-Contra scandal, he tries to run his group of spies as a CIA in miniature. Working from his house in a San Diego suburb, he uses e-mail to stay in contact with his agents in Afghanistan and Pakistan, writing up intelligence summaries based on their reports, according to associates.

In 2009, the security firm that Clarridge was affiliated with, the American International Security Corp., won a Pentagon contract ultimately worth about $6 million. U.S. officials said the contract was arranged by Michael Furlong, a senior Defense Department civilian with a military information warfare command at San Antonio’s Lackland Air Force Base.

To get around a military ban on hiring contractors as spies, a Pentagon report says that Furlong’s team called its activities atmospheric information rather than intelligence.

Furlong, now the subject of a criminal investigation by the Pentagon’s inspector general, was accused in the Pentagon report of carrying out unauthorized intelligence-gathering and misleading senior military officers about it.

It is difficult to assess the merits of Clarridge’s secret intelligence dispatches; a review of some of the documents by The Times shows that some appear to be based on rumors from talk at village bazaars or rehashes of news reports.

Others, though, contain specific details about militant plans to attack U.S. troops and about Taliban leadership meetings in Pakistan. Clarridge gave the military an in-depth report about the Haqqani militant group in August 2009, a document that officials said helped the military track Haqqani fighters.

When the military wouldn’t listen to him, Clarridge found other ways to peddle his information. For instance, his private spies in April and May were reporting that Mullah Muhammad Omar, leader of the Afghan Taliban, had been caught by Pakistani officials and put under house arrest. Both military and intelligence officials said the allegation couldn’t be corroborated, but Clarridge used back channels to pass it on to senior Obama administration officials. And associates said that Clarridge, determined to make the allegations public, arranged for it to get to Thor, a regular guest on Beck’s program on Fox News.

Taking aim in Afghanistan

Clarridge and his spy network also took sides in a battle over Ahmed Wali Karzai, head of the Kandahar Provincial Council. For years, the U.S. military has believed that Ahmed Wali Karzai plays a central role in Afghan corruption, though he denies any links to drug trafficking.

In early 2010, Clarridge helped produce a dossier for U.S. military commanders detailing allegations about the Afghan official’s drug connections, land grabs and even murders. The document speculates that Ahmed Wali Karzai’s ties to the CIA — which has paid him an undetermined amount of money since 2001 — might be the reason the agency “is the only member of the country team in Kabul not to advocate taking a more active stance against AWK.”

Ultimately, the military couldn’t amass enough proof to convince other U.S. officials of his reputed crimes and backed off efforts to remove him from power.

There have long been rumors that Hamid Karzai uses drugs, in part because of his often erratic behavior. U.S. officials have said publicly that there is no evidence to support the allegation.

Clarridge pushed a plan to prove that the president was a heroin addict and then confront him with the evidence to ensure that he became a more pliable ally. Clarridge proposed various ideas, according to several associates, such as trying to find a way to collect Hamid Karzai’s beard trimmings and test them. He dropped his ideas when the Obama administration signaled that it was committed to Karzai’s government.

But Clarridge, his associates say, continues to dream up operations against the Afghan leader and his inner circle.

When he was an official spy, Clarridge recalled in his 1997 memoir, he bristled at the CIA’s bureaucracy for thwarting his plans to do maximum harm to America’s enemies. “It’s not like I’m running my own private CIA,” he wrote, “and can do what I want.”

End article I found on this interesting source: There Are No Sunglasses here

Duane Clarridge Clarridge, Duane R. ("Dewey"), with Digby Diehl. A Spy for All Seasons: My Life in the CIA. New York: Scribner's, 1997. A fair review here

Duane R. Clarridge - SourceWatch here

INTERVIEW WITH DUANE CLARRIDGE here

New York Times, "he has fielded operatives in the mountains of Pakistan" and keeps in touch with his agents by way of email (He Never Left) Former CIA agent Duane Clarridge, who was indicted in 1991 in connection with the Iran-Contra affair, has reemerged in Pakistan here

UPDATE: Pakistani court throws out Raymond Davis immunity plea

Raymond Davis and the American Media on Forbes blog
Mar. 5 2011 - 11:59 am | 243 views | 0 recommendations | 0 comments
By MAHA ATAL
The Raymond Davis saga in Pakistan is far from over, and I’ll have a piece sooner or later on the implications, broadly, for US-Pak relations. But there’s a meta-story that’s worth taking note of now: the coverage of the story in the Pakistani and international press. Essentially, Davis’ CIA status was being floated in the Pakistani press for several weeks before it ‘broke’ in the Guardian. It turned out that the New York Times and other American news organizations had deliberately held back the information at the request of U.S. authorities. Though a similar request was made of the Guardian, the paper’s editors and reporters refused.

As a reader of the Pakistani press, I’d seen the CIA claim, but in part because of the easy way in which the CIA is used as a bogeyman in Pakistani political discourse, I must admit I was skeptical of the claim until the Guardian verified it. As a critic of the Times’ inconsistent policy about withholding information for ‘the safety of the subject,’ I’m disappointed, but unsurprised, by their call on this one. Points to the Guardian for getting it right. For more on the details, this video from Al Jazeera’s media-watch show, Listening Post, is good.

The story is amusing coming on the heels of Hillary Clinton’s takedown of the American media at the Senate Foreign Relations Committee this week. Clinton asserted that the U.S. is losing the global information war because of the frivolity in American journalism: you don’t feel when watching American news stations, she says, that you are getting real news.

Problematically, one reason American news outlets don’t deliver enough ‘real news’ is because they comply too readily with the intelligence agencies trying to win that information war. Yet another example of misaligned agendas coming from the State Department and the CIA.




AP photo

As background be sure to read this crucial article
here


Source: OUR STAFF REPORTER Submitted - 4 March 2011 LAHORE -

Additional District and Sessions Judge (AD&SJ) Muhammad Yousaf Aujla on Thursday turned down the claim for diplomatic immunity submitted by the counsel for double murder accused Raymond Davis.

The judge said the trial would continue against US national Raymond because so far no directives or decision of any court regarding diplomatic immunity for him has been dispatched to his court. This he said in response to Davis counsel’s plea that trial by the AD&SJ shouldn’t proceed when the Lahore High Court decides on the immunity petition.

The trial proceedings of the double murder were held Thursday in the Kot Lakhpat jail, and Judge Muhammad Yousaf Aujla also extended the judicial remand of Davis till March 15 in the case of illegal arms. The court directed the police to submit a complete challan (charge sheet) of the case on the next hearing. Most local and international media were once again kept from the trial proceedings of the cases against Davis, the CIA operative who had killed two Pakistanis in Lahore at Qartaba Chowk on January 27. Only US Consul General Carmella Conroy could grant permission for the media to attend the proceedings.

Davis was produced by jail authorities before the court set up in the Kot Lakhpat jail. On the last hearing, Davis challenged the court concerned that it could not hold the trial of the cases against him because he enjoyed diplomatic immunity.

On Wednesday, counsel for Raymond Davis — LHC former judge Syed Zahid Hussain Bokhari – filed his objection with the court that it could not try his client as he also produced and submitted a note of the US Embassy before the court in this regard.

The note said that Raymond Davis enjoys diplomatic immunity as he is having a diplomatic passport.

Bokhari along with two other lawyers informed the court that the matter of diplomatic immunity for Davis was also pending before the Lahore High Court, on which the judge said that so far he had not received any directives or copy of decision in this regard by any higher court that Davis could not be tried in this court.

The counsel for the complainant Asad Butt said legal certificate (proof of diplomatic immunity) should have been provided by the Davis counsel. He pleaded that only note of the US Embassy was not sufficient.

The court agreed that the document (the embassy note) was not sufficient as it has no legal value and authenticity before this court. The court rejected the claim and application submitted by Davis counsel for diplomatic immunity, with remarks that this court could try US national Raymond Davis in the double murder case because this is falling in its jurisdiction.

Davis counsel informed the judge that so far he has not been provided with the copies of the documents as well as complete copy of the charge sheet. The judge directed the Prosecution Department to provide the documents to the counsel.

http://nation.com.pk/pakistan-news-newspaper-daily-english-online//Politics/04-Mar-2011/Court-throws-out-Davis-immunity-plea

easy click here

========
See this Wikipedia entry for a partial review of this case here